Why We’re So Bad at Asking for What We Want in Bed

You want something specific. Something filthy. Something that lives in your head rent-free.

But instead of asking, you stay quiet. You hope they’ll guess. You wait for the right moment that never comes. And then you leave the bedroom with a weird mix of satisfaction and resentment.

If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Most people are terrible at asking for what they want in bed.

Here’s why and how to change that.

We Were Taught That Wanting Is Embarrassing

From the second we hit puberty, we’re flooded with mixed messages:

  • Don’t be too eager

  • Don’t be too aggressive

  • Don’t be too needy

  • Don’t be too much

Especially if you’re a woman, queer, or raised in a conservative culture, the message is clear. Wanting sex is fine. Wanting something specific? That’s dirty. Shameful. Awkward.

So we learn to go with the flow. Stay chill. Be “easy to please.” Even when we’re not.

Rejection Feels Like Personal Failure

It’s not just about asking. It’s about the fear of hearing “no.”

Because if we ask for choking, praise, anal, foot worship and someone says “eh, not my thing”, it feels like a rejection of us. Like we exposed something raw and got punished for it.

That’s not true. But it feels true. And that fear? It keeps a lot of mouths shut and a lot of bodies unsatisfied.

We Assume They Should Just Know

We’ve all fallen into the trap of thinking:

  • “If they really cared, they’d figure it out.”

  • “If they were good in bed, they’d know what I need.”

  • “I shouldn’t have to ask.”

But sex isn’t mind reading. It’s collaboration. What worked for their last partner might do nothing for you. What they think “turns you on” might actually turn you off.

Your orgasm isn’t a test of their skill, it’s a shared effort. And if you don’t give them the cheat codes, you both lose.

We’ve Had Bad Experiences

Let’s be real, some of us have asked before. And it didn’t go well.

Maybe they laughed. Maybe they looked confused. Maybe they tried once and never again. Maybe they said, “That’s weird.”

That kind of reaction can shut you down hard. It hurts. And it creates a protective silence that’s hard to break.

But not everyone will react that way. And the right person? Will listen, lean in, and want to know more.

So What Happens When We Don’t Ask

The obvious answer, we don’t get what we want. But it’s bigger than that.

  • We start to detach

  • We feel unseen

  • We moan and fake it instead of feeling it

  • We blame our partners instead of guiding them

  • We convince ourselves we’re “just not sexual people”

Silence doesn’t protect you. It buries you. And it creates a version of sex that might look good on the outside but leaves you cold underneath.

Asking Can Be Sexy, Not Scary

Let’s flip the script. Asking isn’t needy. It’s confident.

It says, “I know what I like. I trust you enough to share it. I want this to feel amazing for both of us.”

Here’s how to make it hot:

  • Whisper it during foreplay: “Want to try something?”

  • Say it like an invitation: “I’d love it if you…”

  • Frame it as curiosity: “Ever tried…?”

  • Use dirty talk as a soft intro: “Bet you’d lose your mind if I…”

The delivery doesn’t have to be perfect. Just honest.

Start Small and Build Up

You don’t have to drop your entire kink list on the table like a buffet.

Start with one thing.

  • A position you like

  • A word you want to hear

  • A toy you want to try

  • A place you want to be touched

The first ask is always the hardest. Once it’s out, the second one gets easier. And the third? Might come with a blindfold and a safe word.

How to Handle It If They Say No

This is the part people avoid, but it’s not the end of the world.

If they’re not into it, that doesn’t mean your desire is bad. It means it’s not for them. You’re not being rejected. You’re being redirected.

Here’s what to do:

  • Ask if there’s a version of it they would be into

  • See if it’s something you can explore solo

  • Leave space for it to be a “maybe later”

  • And if it’s core to your sexuality? Have the bigger conversation, lovingly, honestly

You deserve to be met. And if they can’t meet you there, you still deserve the thing.

TLDR for the Speechless but Horny

  • Asking for what you want doesn’t make you high maintenance, it makes you brave

  • Shame, fear, and past rejection keep us quiet

  • Silence kills good sex faster than a bad rhythm

  • The right people will listen, ask back, and lean in

  • You’re allowed to want things and say them out loud

You don’t need to scream your desires from the rooftop. But whisper them to someone who wants to hear and watch what happens when they finally get it right.

Next
Next

The Art of the Pre-Sex Debrief, No It’s Not a Mood Killer